This article is the 1st part (and introduction) to a 9 part series on Universal Restoration vs Eternal Torment (hell).
- Universal Restoration vs Eternal Torment (hell) introduction (You are here)
- The Biggest Hole in Hell: Aion, Ages and Eternity
- Can you be saved after you die?
- So let’s talk a little bit about the word “hell”
- Scriptures That Support Universal Restoration
- Scriptures In Revelation That Support Universal Restoration
- So why did Jesus die if not to save us from hell?
- The Early Church Fathers on Universal Restoration
- Universal Restoration vs Eternal Torment Conclusion
Is Hell Forever?
The obvious answer that virtually all Christians would reply immediately is “yes”.
In a nutshell, the life and afterlife goes like this according to the traditional view:
You are born, and while living on earth either come to a saving faith in Jesus Christ or don’t. If you are a believer, then when you die you go to heaven and spend the rest of forever in paradise with God. If you don’t believe, then you are thrown into the lake of fire to be tormented for the rest of forever for your sins.
This is basic Christian doctrine and denying it would be considered heresy.
A while ago, a friend who loves God deeply and is Very smart (smart enough to find a mistake on an IQ test) started questioning this doctrine. And I do mean honestly questioning. They weren’t out to stir up trouble; they had legitimate concerns that our understanding of the afterlife and hell was wrong.
They had found some scripture that seemed to indicate that hell was not forever. Rather, that it was temporary and eventually all of mankind would end up in heaven with God. (Called “Universal Restoration” or “Universalism”)
And yes, I know that’s heresy.
They shared those concerns with me and I figured I’d look into it for five minutes and solve it for them. I was wrong. Instead of a shallow “whishy-washy” theology, I found enough scripture supporting their position so I decided to dig deep.
Universalism agrees with the traditional view on all points view except one. They believe that hell is not “Eternal Torment”, but rather “Temporary Discipline”. The Universal Restoration position believes that you can be saved after death. They believe that the lake of fire is the final and harshest thing God uses to turn wicked and unrepentant hearts toward Himself. And once a sinner in hell repents and turns toward God, they too will be saved.
In all other respects, they believe that same as Orthodox Christianity.
What follows is my research laid out with as little bias as possible. Everyone has a bias. I have tried as much as possible to keep my bias out of this paper, but I’m sure I wasn’t completely successful.
To be clear I am NOT arguing for OR against either position.
Honestly, I’m writing this out to help organize my own thoughts. I always understand things better after sitting down and writing them out. This article is the result of my search for a place to “plant my doctrinal flag” on the fate of Mankind in the afterlife.
An Overview of Hell (Eternal Torment)
I will only spend a little time here because hell is a well know doctrine. The existence of hell hinges on two points. Without them, there is simply no foundation for the doctrine. Those two points are the use of the word “eternal” and the cultural context of the word translated “hell”.
The points below are only a quick overview, NOT an in-depth treatment.
We will examine them much more closely in separate articles. For now, I’m just looking to give you a brief overview.
Pillar #1: The Word Translated “Eternal”
There are several phrases which commonly come to mind when discussing hell. Phrases like “eternal punishment”, “eternal destruction”, etc. However, the word translated “eternal” there doesn’t necessarily mean eternal. For example:
3 As He was sitting on the Mount of Olives, the disciples came to Him privately, saying, “Tell us, when will these things happen, and what will be the sign of Your coming, and of the end of the age?”
The word above I’ve highlighted in red is the exact same word as the word translated “eternal” in every single verse where the duration of punishment in the afterlife is discussed.
If you look up the definition of the Greek word, it means “age”. Further, that word has a a plural form meaning “ages”. Does it make sense to say “eternities” or “forevers”? Once you understand the meaning of this word, you’ll realize the foundation for eternal torment (hell) rests on very shaky ground.
(Also, the “unforgivable sin” verse is the most egregious example of mis-translation in the Bible. For starters, virtually every translation omits three important Greek words that complete change the meaning.)
Pillar #2: The Ever-Burning Burning Garbage Pit
In several places, Jesus references “hell”. The word He uses is the Greek word Gehenna, which refers to the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem. Most scholars agree that this valley was essentially a great burning trash heap. The people of Jerusalem would throw all their garbage into it and because it was constantly being fed, the fire would never go out.
However, this view doesn’t line up with history.
The first time anyone described “Gehenna” (The Valley of Hinnom) this way was over a thousand years after Christ. Further, archeologists have recently uncovered an orderly landfill outside Jerusalem in the neighboring Kidron valley. This landfill was used during Jesus’ entire lifetime and for a couple decades afterward. Further, it was designed so that it wouldn’t smell or be an eyesore.
Why would they have a great stinking, burning, sooty garbage dump on one side of Jerusalem and a clean, orderly (almost modern) landfill on another side?
It makes zero sense to believe they did.
Once those two pillars are dealt with, you’ll see that a scriptural basis for eternal torment (hell) rests on a foundation of shifting sand.
An Overview of Universal Restoration
Below are some of the main pillars of the Universal Restoration school of thought.
Again, the points below are only a quick overview NOT an in-depth treatment.
The Bible Never Says You Can’t Be Saved After Death
It’s not in there.
You can scour the book from end to end and not find it… except for possibly one parable the Jesus tells. In Luke 16, Jesus tells the parable of Lazarus and the Rich man. It makes reference to a “great chasm” between reward and punishment in the afterlife.
However, if you read it in context you will see that Jesus is – like with all parables – making an analogy. Once you understand a few things about their culture and history, the true meaning of this parable becomes obvious.
Besides, why is this the only one of Jesus parables we take literally?
Isn’t a parable just a story by definition?
Further, if this parable is literal you have to believe something strange. If this parable is literal, then Christians will be able to see and talk to our unsaved friends/family in the afterlife… While they are being tormented for all eternity. From heaven, you will see them tormented in hell for all time.
The Gospel Has Been Preached To The Dead
Believe it or not, Jesus himself preached the Gospel to the dead. (after His death and before His resurrection)
1 Peter 4:6
6 For the gospel has for this purpose been preached even to those who are dead, that though they are judged in the flesh as men, they may live in the spirit according to the will of God.
If you back up and read the context, you’ll discover the dead Jesus is speaking to here were (at least) the evil men of Noah’s day. You know, the men who were so wicked that God destroyed the entire world. Yup, those wicked men. According to this verse, they were dead and “judged in the flesh as men” but now “live in the spirit”. The phrase “live in the spirit” certainly sounds like being saved to me.
This is made even more clear by a verse in Ephesians. It talks about Jesus leading s “host of captives” on high after “descending to the lower parts of the earth” (a common slang term for punishment in the afterlife; even today we say “down to hell” vs. “up to heaven”)
The Invitation in Revelation
The last 4 verses in Revelation are warnings not to change the book and closing. However, the last thing in revelation before the warnings and the closing is an invitation:
17 The Spirit and the bride say, “Come.” And let the one who hears say, “Come.” And let the one who is thirsty come; let the one who wishes take the water of life without cost.
The Spirit is obviously God and the Bride is obviously the Church (the Bride of Christ). So… Who are they talking to? If God and all believers are issuing this invitation, who is being invited?
Since they are being invited to “take the water of life” (an obvious reference to being saved) then wouldn’t they be talking to people to don’t have the water of life? Wouldn’t that be unbelievers? If I was being tormented in a lake of fire, I think the water of life would be pretty appealing. Don’t you?
Further, we know from Revelation 21:25 that the gates of heaven will never be shut. (and in Rev 22:14 they issue a blessing to those who “wash their robes” so they can enter into the city “by the gate”.)
Could the last passage of the bible (except the warning and closing) be an invitation for everyone to be saved after they die?
I think so.
Jesus Watches A Torture Show? What?
9 Then another angel, a third one, followed them, saying with a loud voice, “If anyone worships the beast and his image, and receives a mark on his forehead or on his hand,
10 he also will drink of the wine of the wrath of God, which is mixed in full strength in the cup of His anger; and he will be tormented with fire and brimstone in the presence of the holy angels and in the presence of the Lamb.
11 “And the smoke of their torment goes up forever and ever (Aion of the Aion); they have no rest day and night, those who worship the beast and his image, and whoever receives the mark of his name.”
(Note: the words translated “forever and ever” here are the same ones who definition mean”age” that we’ve already talked about)
If Eternal Torment is true, then Jesus will be standing in the midst of this torment for all eternity. Essentially, Jesus will be watching a torture show forever. How does that line up with the Jesus you know? How does that line up with “love you enemies”?
If Universal Restoration is correct, then Jesus isn’t there to watch; He’s there to pull people out the moment they repent. (like a lifeguard at a pool). That’s the Jesus I know.
Punishment is correction/discipline, not punishment for punishment’s sake
In the New Testament, the words used for “punishment” in the afterlife don’t exactly mean “punishment”. They come from the root word which means “to prune”. When you prune something, you cut away everything that’s bad for the plant in order to help it grow stronger. The end goal is the good of the plant.
These are the words Jesus uses to describe the “punishment” in the afterlife. (I think “discipline” is a better translation)
The Bible does use words to describe punishment for punishment’s sake. For example, punishment for a crime. However, these words are never used to talk about punishment in the afterlife.
(I will prove all of the below in the article on The Early Church Fathers)
It might surprise you to learn that for the first ~500 years of Christianity, eternal torment in hell wasn’t the most common view. In fact, the idea of eternal torment in hell was arguably a fringe idea for about 300 years after Christ. (which I can and will prove in the articles.)
Just one quick proof.
There were six major Christian theological schools in the early church. Of them, 4 taught Universal Restoration while only 1 taught Eternal torment. There were many other minor schools, nearly all of which were founded by people who believed Universal Restoration.
Further, most of the early Church Fathers who championed the idea of Eternal torment didn’t speak or read Greek. Therefore they read the New Testament Scriptures in a Latin translation instead of the the original Greek. The rise of eternal torment as a majority view coincided with the rise of Latin (and decline of Greek) as the common language.
In other words, Eternal Torment (hell) became popular when people stopped reading the original Greek and started using a Latin translation.
It may also surprise you to know that the Jewish people never believed in Eternal Torment (hell). They don’t believe it even to this day. They have always believed that punishment in the afterlife was limited in duration. In fact, the only significant sect of Jews who ever believed in eternal torment were the Pharisees of Jesus day.
But it gets worse.
Eternal torment wasn’t officially adopted until 543 AD when the Roman Emperor Justinian called a Church council to make Universalism heresy. (By adopting an official declaration he himself wrote.) As for Emperor Justinian’s character, he murdered 30,000 innocent civilians during the Nika riots to secure his power. That’s not exactly the kind of person I want dictating Church doctrine.
Therefore, a mass murderer is responsible for forcing the Church to adopt Eternal Torment as it’s official teaching.
(Didn’t learn that in Church history did you?)
The above represents a very brief overview of both Eternal Torment and Universal Restoration. I will go into much more detail in the articles below. However, that should give you a good overview.
One more thing I will add. I personally believe the believing Universalism produces more sincere and real Christians than believing eternal torment. Why? Because of Romans.
4 Or do you think lightly of the riches of His kindness and tolerance and patience, not knowing that the kindness of God leads you to repentance?
Fear of hellfire can make a person change their actions, but won’t do anything for the heart. However, heart sins like hatred (which equals murder) and lust (which equals adultery) need a heart change. John
If the kindness of God leads you to repentance, than isn’t preaching hellfire counter-productive?
I know that turns evangelism on its head, but have you ever met a Christian who was truly and deeply seeking God because they were afraid of hell?
The next article in this series is: The Biggest Hole in Hell: Aion, Ages and Eternity